More ebay junk? [Archive] - SR20 Forum

: More ebay junk?


astroboy
02-06-2010, 11:29 PM
http://cgi.ebay.ca/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=270450484651&ssPageName=ADME:X:RTQ:CA:1123

I sent them an email asking about them, spring rates are 7.5 for front and 4.5 for rear, they also said if they were to start leaking in the first year they would replace them. I can't help but to think they are crap. The pic doesn't look bad but I would rather have a solid product than a nice pic. Anybody ever hear of these, have any opinions?

bj200sx
02-07-2010, 01:03 AM
from what i heard they are crap. i didn't the same thing and posted a link on the forum and got that response.

astroboy
02-07-2010, 09:42 AM
I sent a message to one of the buysers (who has a b13) and he said they are very good and he likes them. I would like to hear from someone who actually bought these. I'll try to find your thread again and copy the link.

wes
02-08-2010, 02:31 PM
They are junk! ANYONE who owns them that has a clue will tell you they suck, anyone who owns them that thinks they are great, has not had them on a shock dyno. nor have they actually used them in a track day setup and compared them to a good suspension that is properly set up.

astroboy
02-08-2010, 08:23 PM
Rite-o, that is what I was thinking hence why I was questioning them. I am getting some bits and pieces coilovers. Thanks for the input!

2.2lvvlb13
02-08-2010, 09:15 PM
all you guys that says it suks or is junk. have u owned it? tried it? rode on it? i bet if it was up for 200 on this forum all of you would be rushing it!

wes
02-08-2010, 09:38 PM
all you guys that says it suks or is junk. have u owned it? tried it? rode on it? i bet if it was up for 200 on this forum all of you would be rushing it!

I wouldn't let someone pay me $200 to put it on my car. I OWN a quality setup that I built myself from Koni parts. I KNOW I is junk as it is the same crap as the Ksport, Megan racing stuff. Crappy quality control by the manufacturer, valving an adjustment does little to nothing.

If you want to buy it go head. But I lump you in the category with others in my previous post. You wouldn't know the difference between that junk and an Advance Design suspension if you drove both on the track.

CoZZm0
02-09-2010, 06:23 AM
They're actually BC Racing coilovers in the V1 design. Different to G4/D2 or Ksports. They're a monotube (non-inverted) and while they may not provide the same excellent damping response as a quality Koni sport twin tube, they're certainly better than some of the other cheap china stuff.

Few poeple locally here in australia have them, as well as the "gold" series which are the model after these with gold collars and tops which are also available in mono inverted fronts and external reservoir versions if requested.

MR-4Door-SR20DET
02-09-2010, 10:08 AM
They are junk! ANYONE who owns them that has a clue will tell you they suck, anyone who owns them that thinks they are great, has not had them on a shock dyno. nor have they actually used them in a track day setup and compared them to a good suspension that is properly set up.

^I trust this statement!

astroboy
02-09-2010, 08:18 PM
I don't think that everybody that is interested in coilovers is taking their car to the track. Also I think that Cozzm0's opinion holds a little more water than shunning them due to the fact they are from ebay. At least he sited un-named people using them even though he never said if they performed well or not. Just my .02

wes
02-10-2010, 10:03 AM
They're actually BC Racing coilovers in the V1 design. Different to G4/D2 or Ksports. They're a monotube (non-inverted) and while they may not provide the same excellent damping response as a quality Koni sport twin tube, they're certainly better than some of the other cheap china stuff.

Few poeple locally here in australia have them, as well as the "gold" series which are the model after these with gold collars and tops which are also available in mono inverted fronts and external reservoir versions if requested.

Does anyone have any plots from a shock dyno, showing the cube and the adjustment range? Also what is the failure rate like with these? Again to leet the price point sacrifices are made somewhere. I am not saying they aren't more performance oriented than the stock suspension...


My point is this, whether you track your car or not, for the same or similar money you could have a suspension that outperforms this in a track or daily driver setting.

My simple Koni setup is so comfortable on the street I often forget it is lowered and track ready. So just because your not going to the track that means it's OK to sacrifice performance and ride and bile quality? Of your OK with that then rock on, afterall it's your car an money.

horishima
02-10-2010, 08:08 PM
What about this, I'm still thinking about getting Progress coilovers but I saw these and never hear of them.
http://www.stdsuspension.com/#

wes
02-10-2010, 11:28 PM
What about this, I'm still thinking about getting Progress coilovers but I saw these and never hear of them.
http://www.stdsuspension.com/#

Stay away from STD's!!!!! Progress....

nismo chris
02-10-2010, 11:57 PM
yea bro go with progress i had a set on my b13 and they were fuckin awsome took the car to the track as well and they handled awsome

CoZZm0
02-11-2010, 04:10 AM
Does anyone have any plots from a shock dyno, showing the cube and the adjustment range? Also what is the failure rate like with these? Again to leet the price point sacrifices are made somewhere. I am not saying they aren't more performance oriented than the stock suspension...


My point is this, whether you track your car or not, for the same or similar money you could have a suspension that outperforms this in a track or daily driver setting.

My simple Koni setup is so comfortable on the street I often forget it is lowered and track ready. So just because your not going to the track that means it's OK to sacrifice performance and ride and bile quality? Of your OK with that then rock on, afterall it's your car an money.

Lots of people are after aesthetics over GENUINE handling and these cheaper coilovers provide that for them. I'm all for handling, but have never had the time/budget/ability to properly research a quality setup, so i've gone the easy route and bought TEIN off the shelf/imported from Japan. Never had a drama with them.

I obtained shock dyno data for the Monotube inverted BC range which showed a MASSIVE difference in soft to hard damp force, which almost seems unlikely to be true? but i'm not sure? Considering the damp force and comparing them to TEIN dyno data i have for superstreet,ha,flex,monoflex, the BC's ride extremely well, and when set "hard" almost seem to not have enough rebound damping as they get a little bouncy, but not "harsh" like the TEIN does, so i guess that points to things not being as "controlled". But i am CERTAINLY no suspension expert. I have had TEIN HA and TEIN Flex in my cars over time.

http://www.bcec.com.tw/products/products.html

that's the manufacturer website. the BR is the 'gold' range, i have ridden in a n N15 (JN15 VZ-R 3 Door) car with RM mono inverted and the ride is very comfortable set a little under 1/2 of the range of damping.

I have done a disassembly of a monotube inverted shock which suffered a fault, but was VERY swiftly replaced. Looked as though the seal (grub screw/bung) for the pressure side of the monotube was not sufficiently locked down and the charge leaked out slowly causing loss of damping. Other than that, i'm not aware of any seal failures or the like for this partciular brand.